Inductis
Who We Are

Who we are

Inductis White Paper
Emerging Trends in Auto Insurance Pricing
Frank Cacchione, Arnab Dey & Ritesh Aggarwal
 

Unlike the number of claims, it is not easy to prove mathematically the optimal modeling technique for the claim severity. However, based on the typical distribution of the claim severity curve, the gamma, lognormal and Pareto3 distribution are the typical candidates to be considered.

In-depth industry knowledge and detailed analytical approach like curve fitting, etc. is required to find the optimal approach especially when the number of claims is small or some claims are of extremely large value (as is the case with BI or PD).

In our experience, Gamma or truncated Gamma functions give superior predictive results as compared to other regression techniques.

Merits of using these new statistical techniques are enormous. However model development is a complex and error-prone process. While many completed models work as planned, some models contain fundamental errors. Moreover, the internal logic of most models is usually very abstract and limiting, so it requires considerable judgment and expertise to apply model results in the appropriate business context.

(C) MODEL STRUCTURE
Traditionally, models are divided into a class plan and a tier plan, with no overlap of variables.

This leads to sub-optimal models as interactions between the two sets of variables are not captured. As a result, companies must adopt a holistic structure. Since every coverage has its own characteristic and behavior with regards to frequency and severity, each coverage should be modeled separately.

One could sometimes group coverages into low frequency high severity (e.g., bodily injury), and high frequency-low severity (e.g., collision). Figure 3 shows a typical distribution of severity and frequency for various coverages.

Once the national level models have been built at the individual coverage level, state specific versions have to be built as well to account for the difference in “regulatorily approved variable set”.

(D) USE OF EXTERNAL DATA
Third party data providers like Polk, Carfax, ISO etc. provide reliable information on driving history, new drivers in a household, car history, etc. to enable better decision making. The emergence of these sources has made collection of the same information from consumers redundant, thus simplifying the quote generation process as well. Figure 4 shows a list of such third party providers.

(E) ALLOCATION OF OTHER EXPENSES
An auto insurance company incurs various loss and non-loss related expenses. A robust pricing methodology should account for all the expenses incurred in addition to loss and LAE, i.e. acquisition
expenses and general indirect expenses. As pricing sophistication develops, all three cost elements should be handled scientifically and passed on to consumers appropriately based on the true cost drivers. While losses (including loss adjustment expenses) represent the biggest component of cost, companies no longer need to use a simple constant factor to allocate acquisition expenses. They can now use measures such as ease of acquiring a customer, conversion rates, his/her retention rate etc. to identify customers who should be allocated higher portion of the acquisition costs. Going forward, we can expect more companies to:

  • Allocate acquisition expense by the underlying drivers of cost, such as geography, response rate, ease of conversion of a quote into a policy, productivity of sales force, dollar value of policy sold, and retention of a customer
  • Allocate at a segment level than at a population level
  • Use sophisticated modeling techniques
  • Get more competitive in market place as pricing becomes optimal at the segment level

ADDRESSING KEY REGULATORY CHALLENGES
Despite all of these technological advances, companies continue to face challenges in the marketplace unique to the insurance industry.

  • Various states impose restrictions on variables that can be used in modeling. This can lead to suboptimal models
  • Statewide differences also lead to increased modeling efforts as models have to be tweaked based on each state’s regulations
However, the greater accuracy and risk specific insights derived from these advanced modeling techniques can provide considerable guidance in reacting to these regulatory conditions and adapting the optimum model to state-specific constraints.

Having the flexibility to assess the impact of removal of certain variables from the model can be extremely helpful in both pricing decisions and marketing strategy. For example, in a recent study we found that removing a key rating variable that was difficult to validate reduced the model’s predictive power only marginally as other factors offset the independent value of this historically important variable.

Companies are still building comprehensive organization wide data assets that help in modeling across a customer lifecycle. As the industry evolves and better uses the tools at its disposal, companies that quickly adopt these advanced analytical methods will emerge winners over the coming years.

ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Frank Cacchione, Associate Partner at Inductis and CEO of TNC Management Group specializes in application of advanced business analytics, systems development and superior project management support for the Insurance industry. He has over 30 years of experience in the domain. Mr. Cacchione’s insurancespecific experience includes leading the Mass Marketing Division and serving on the Boards of AI Life and AIG Marketing. He has also been a Partner at several leading management consulting firms, namely, Tillinghast/TPF&C, the Vice-President of AMRE
Consultants, a subsidiary of American Reinsurance, Mitchell Madison Group and PA Consulting.

He can be reached at
fcacchione@tncmanagement.com or +1-917-446-0264.

Arnab Dey, Principal at Inductis, has advised a number of large financial services and insurance clients on product pricing, market segmentation, retention, underwriting and collection strategy. Prior to Inductis, Mr. Dey worked with Mitchell Madison Group and Deutsche Bank. He holds an MBA from Indian Institute of Management (IIM), Ahmedabad, and a B.Tech in Computer Science from the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT), Kharagpur.

He can be reached at
adey@inductis.com or +1-212-284-3306.

Ritesh Aggarwal
, Lead Project Manager at Inductis, has advised a number of large financial services and insurance clients on loyalty program management, retention strategy and pricing strategy. Mr. Aggarwal holds an MBA from Indian Institute of Management (IIM), Ahmedabad, and a B.Tech in Mechanical Engineering from the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT), Bombay.

He can be reached at
raggarwal@inductis.com or +1-212-284-3329.

Geet Bhanawat is a Project Manager at Inductis.

ABOUT INDUCTIS AND TNC MANAGEMENT GROUP
Inductis is a global professional services firm that helps large companies leverage the information age to make better decisions through deep analytics. We focus on value creation through our two practice areas: Management Consulting and Analytics Services.

TNC Management Group is involved in Management Consulting and Project Management for the Insurance Industry. Its business strategy, project management, systems and operational expertise has helped clients to rapidly assess and implement change focused on enhancing customer value and measurable bottom line
improvement.

    Page 1 2
Quick Links for Financial and Insurance Consulting Services and More...
Apply For Insurance Consulting Services-Inductis

APPLY TO INDUCTIS

Inductis - Focusing On Professional Financial Consulting & Insurance Services
FOCUS AREAS
Case Study of Best Financial Consulting Services & Insurance Consulting-Inductis and More...
CASE STUDIES
  Select examples of how Inductis teams have achieved results for a variety of clients ...more >>
Best Financial Consulting Company- Inductis
PUBLICATIONS
  Our thoughts on how organizations can elevate their performance ...more >>
Site Map -Inductis
SITE MAP
Contact Us for Financial Services and Insurance Consulting Services - Inductis
CONTACT US
Copyright © 2002 - 2008 Inductis Inc.